Sunday, August 28, 2011
Answering Tovia Singer: An Introduction
Today, we begin our answering the anti-missionaries series. I intend to focus on specific anti-missionaries, give their backgrounds, and show you their arguments and rhetorical tricks, so that you can better debate them.
Perhaps the most famous anti-missionary is Tovia Singer. He is a charming and charismatic speaker, sort of the Rabbinic version of Ahmed Deedat. Neither is much of a scholar, but both are fantastic showmen, able to stir up crowds with their golden-tongued rhetoric.
I heard from a Messianic Rabbi who apparently was a long-time friend of Rabbi Singer, that Singer at one point in his life almost became a Messianic Jew. After rejecting this option, its seems that Singer decided to pursue a career to keep his fellow Jews away from Jesus at any cost. He is now the director of Outreach Judasim. He has his own radio show in Israel and his own tape series and study companion, both titled Let's Get Biblical.
As Michael Flanigan gives in his testimonial for Singer's book: "Check all the references to Strong's Driver and Briggs, or any other resource you have." I couldn't agree more. Two resources I recommend for a more in-depth study are biblos.com which has the Bible in almost every conceivable language, interlinear versions, and Strong's numbers for further research. The other is the Blue Letter Bible, which gives you access to word study tools. Both are completely free, and don't even require you to register!
In fact, I recommend that every Biblical apologist go through Singer's material with a Bible study group. Nearly all the apologetics disasters come from Lone Ranger apologists.
That said, go slowly through Singer's tapes and his study guide and thoroughly research answers to his objections. This will take a lot of time, a matter of years. Be patient and keep plugging along, because if you can finish this monstrous series, you will be prepared to obliterate almost any Biblical skeptic in debate.
For the rest of you who do not want to engage in such a humongous chore, you can just cheat. James Trimm has released an audio series with a lot of the answers to Singer's objections in his Let's Get Truthful audio series. Michael Brown has also released his own audio series called Countering the Counter-Missionaries. He also gives even more detailed responses in his five volume book series Answering Jewish Objections to Jesus.
My series will not attempt to provide any sort of an exhaustive answer to Tovia Singer's objections, which may at first glance seem overpowering, but take heart. Singer is a powerful speaker, but a weak Biblical scholar who makes a lot of basic errors. I intend to not only expose some of his errors but I also intend to bring something unique to the table: an explanation of how Tovia uses his rhetorical skills to make a relatively weak argument sound much, much stronger than it actually is. So yes, Tovia. Let's get Biblical.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Hi Drew,
ReplyDeleteThanks for all the work you do, it is really helpful!
I have been chatting to Jewish friend of mine and has been really good and beneficial and your work has been a good help.
I felt we were making good progress. However the other day he sent me a load of youtube links and i normally think they are pretty rubbish but these are pretty good! I will summarise what they argue and also give you the links!
If you could comment on them that would be so helpful as you seem to be an expert in this field.
The video basically argues about the messianic prophecies, and tries to show how the NT writers have misapplied, misquoted and fabricated prophecies.
The man on the video also goes through common christian responses and refutes them. My strong areas are not really biblical text stuff, rather philosophy stuff!
If you can try and reply that would be great, as i need to reply to this guy! (My Jewish friend, but also if we had something to say to this guy on youtube that would be great too!)
The man on the video claims that the messianic prophecies are fabricated, misquoted and the ones we use about the crucifixion are just wrong.
In regards to the fabricated ones he quotes Matt 2:23, Matt 27:9-10 and John 2:17. Basically the claim is that they are not prophecies to be found anywhere in the Hebrew scriptures.
In regards to the misquoted ones he cites Matt 2:14-15, Matt 1:22-23, Isaiah 7:14 and Isaiah 53. He says they are not about Jesus and never were intended to be, they are about Israel and mostly we Christians just try to make it fit out theology. He makes some good points about both the above, fabricated and misquoted.
Finally the crucifixion prophecies. He cites Zechariah 13:6 and says this passage is about a false prophet not Christ, Psalm 22:16 and says it was never meant to say pierced but rather lions gouged or something like that. He says the most we can do is say this is a complicated verse. Psalm 38:11 says this is misapplied to Jesus and in John's gospel the women are close to Jesus where as in Luke's they are far away, and says this is a contradiction. Finally Psalm 34:20 and finally he says this does not apply to Jesus either when read in context.
His main contention is that overall most of this stuff is taken out of context and shouldn't be, it applies to Israel or a single person. On the fabricated one, he does not allow for the reading prophecy to be said its a general overview and stats one of them is not even in the close to being in the hebrew scriptures, the one regarding the potters field.
Anyway if you can help me out that would be great!
So yeh, help would be great! Thanks
Ben
These are the links if your interested and have time to have a look!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wx5EKaY1B8g
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sv0pgcHkrP0
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UyHCxl-5a0A
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4RjJXduuNlg
How much of a "friend" are you if you're trying to convert a Jew? Jesus was a Jew, not a Christian. You're just extending the Holocaust (the Gentile name, of course. Look up what the word means. Jews use "Shoah.") Christians are guilty of the deaths of millions of Jews. Some "friend."
ReplyDeleteThat is nonsense. Christians were responsible for *stopping* Nazi Germany from taking over the world and killing more Jews, and since Israel's creation it has been the Christians in the United States who have ensured that the US has a friendly policy towards Israel. As for the word 'Holocaust' versus 'Shoah', either is acceptable.
Delete